The leadership of the Jehovah's Witnesses sometimes refers to the days of Russell as though the Jehovah's Witnesses and their organization were existing in those days. As a result, the dogmatism of the "Jehovah's organization" concept and many of the teachings related to that concept are often attributed to Charles Taze Russell. Nevertheless, the reality is that Russell never taught that "the true church" is represented on earth by any such authoritarian "visible organization" such as the Jehovah's Witnesses. Russell never spoke of "Jehovah's organization," although he did on very few occasions speak of "the Lord's organization," yet an examination of the context shows that he was not speaking of such in the same sense of Rutherford's "Jehovah's organization" dogma.
In this research, we will be presenting a lot of quotes from Russell that demonstrate what he actually believed and taught about "organization," as that word may be seen as related to the kind of organization that Rutherford created after Russell died. These quotes demonstrate that, even until his death, he never believed in the idea that anyone should set themselves up or be set up as "the authority" in the church.
The carnal mind usually cannot conceive of a unity of faith without some kind of visible organization with some man or men in control of that organization. Over the years there have been several attempts to unite the various sects and denominations of Christendom into one body of believers. To some extent, this has proved successful in producing what is often referred to as the World Council of Churches, which is actually a confederation of various denominations. And yet this confederation is sectarian in that demands belief in the extra-Biblical doctrine of the trinity in order to be members of this council. Is this, however, the unity of the spirit that is spoken of in the Bible?
Russell wrote of such a confederation:
Neither our Lord nor the Apostle Paul referred to a union of denominations. They preached an individual union with Christ, and a consequent relationship of all justified and consecrated believers to each other in the one Lord, one faith and one baptism.This union already exists, except to the extent that denominational creed-fences and social usages separate the Lord's sheep. Wherever and whenever the Lord's sheep meet they may and do quickly identify themselves to each other, and the heart union and fellowship and joy in the Lord they experience cannot even be imitated by creedal bonds.
The union of the Church to which our Lord referred in his prayer, "That they all may be one," was this union of heart already and always experienced by the true members of the "one body," – and additionally he referred to the actual union of all such with himself by the resurrection "change" from flesh and blood to spirit being – to be with him and like him and to share his glory and power and great work for the world, which he mentions just following, viz.: "that the world [during the Millennium] may believe."
"Arguments for Christian Unity", Watch Tower, July 1, 1904, pag 195
However, most Christians are still carnally minded along these lines, and many, believing that they can force a visible unity, have fallen into the same kind of trap that produced the Papal Reign. Russell, somewhat weakly, fought against the tendency, but even in his time, his associates were evidently highly influenced by the carnal mind into thinking that the “church” should have a visible organization in order to be visibly united. After his death, this sectarian way of thinking came to the front, which led to the creation of the Jehovah's Witnesses organization. Rutherford openly created the very kind of sectarian organization that Russell had preached against.
Some have claimed that Russell actually did believe in such an organization. One quote has been presented to us as proof that Russell did believe in such an organization and that early in his ministry. The quote given is from the Watch Tower, March 1883, page 458:
One should note that Russell was not preaching in favor of such an organization, but rather he was simply stating that such an organization would appear acceptable to the "natural man." By this, Russell meant one who had not been regenerated through begettal of the Holy Spirit. And then, speaking of true Christians, Russell presented the idea that they are a company of people without a visible organization. The natural man thinks he needs a visible organization in order to get anything accomplished. In fact, this was similar to the argument that Rutherford presented after Russell died, and it is the same line of reasoning that we have heard Jehovah's Witnesses continue to present. Indeed, Rutherford's doctrine was to draw a "great multitude" of natural, unregenerated people into his visible organization, which he and his associates basically created. And thus, this "great multitude" of natural men would be under the authority of Rutherford and his associates, similar to the way the Papacy sought to bring all under its authority.
Russell continued:
But, though it is impossible for the natural man to see our organization, because he cannot understand the things of the Spirit of God, we trust that you can see that the true Church is most effectually organized, and in the best possible working order. (See the plan of our organization, as stated in the October issue, under the caption "The Ekklesia.") The Apostle Paul urges all to unity of faith and purpose (Phil. 3:15,16-- Diaglott.) All led by the same Spirit may and do come to a knowledge of the same truth. Under our Captain, all the truly sanctified, however few or far separated in person, are closely united by the Spirit of Christ, in faith, hope and love; and, in following the Master's command, are moving in solid battalions for the accomplishment of his purposes. But, bear in mind, God is not dependent upon numbers (See Judges 7, as an illustration).
Please note that Russell did not say that the church is without "organization" at all, but rather that it is an organization overruled by God's spirit, with Jesus as its head. In effect, it is what many have called an "invisible" organization, since it is not seen as a "visible" organization. The true church does not need any other head here on earth to direct the work of Jesus. And, yes, it is true that such a non-visible organization will not draw large crowds of people who appreciate its existence. While large crowds may draw out curiosity, most will prove themselves to not be interested in actually worshiping God in spirit and truth. God, however, is only seeking a few who are genuinely interested in worshiping him in spirit and truth. (John 4:23,24; Philippians 3:3)
Nevertheless, we believe that history shows that even the later experiences of the Bible Students began to draw large crowds of mostly carnally minded people as the Bible Students began to become more and more organized. Even while Russell was alive, although he personally continued to speak out against a visible organization, many of his associates had begun to preach what could be called an organization with Russell or Russell's Watch Tower Society as the only way to this or that. Russell did state above that all being led by the Holy Spirit "do come to a knowledge of the same truth." We believe this can only be fully accomplished in the age to come. Applying this to this present age, and making such an idea a "doctrine" would lead to the creation of a sect, with someone here on earth alleged to be the person or persons who supposedly would supply such truth. There are many of the regenerated children of God who, in all their present life, remain as "babes in Christ" in this respect, and thus we do believe that the consecrated children of God in this age will not all come to an agreement on every aspect of doctrine.
We also need to note that Russell's view of the harvest was that it was to be a visible, physical harvest, a visible separation from the various churches into the association of Bible Students. Russell usually referred to the church as being only the 144,000 joint-heirs with Christ, although at times he seemed to include the "great company" as part of the church. Nevertheless, he apparently believed that the harvest was a physical separation from the various sectarian churches into the Bible Students movement. It appears that he may have been referring to all coming to the same knowledge of the truth as the result of the harvest and association with the Bible Students. Sadly, whether consciously or without consciously realizing it, these teachings were leading to the creation of what could be called a sectarian '"organization," whether it was officially called an organization or not. As a service, there would be nothing wrong with an organization in order to accomplish this or that goal. But, when it becomes doctrine, it goes beyond just creating an organization to accomplish certain immediate goals, without viewing the organization as being "the church." Nevertheless, what could be called an "organization" did actually form around Russell himself, and a visible system was created and even taught as being doctrine. Those who were perceived as in agreement with Russell were often referred to as being "the church." Although Russell himself did not agree with such, in effect, this would mean that all others who were not associated with the Bible Students were not "the church". The general view became that if one did not accept what was perceived as being what Russell taught that one was "not in the truth", which scripturally speaking, would mean that if one that did accept Russell's teachings, he was not in Christ, although it may have been that many did not see that correlation. (John 14:16) It did, however appear to be the general view was that all those remaining of the 144,000 still in the present life would have to come into agreement with what Russell taught. Is such sectarianism? Scripturally, we can only conclude that it is. Please note that most of what we have presented is not actually what Russell himself taught, but it was what was being believed and practiced by most of his associates.
Russell continued:
Recognizing this organization, which is of the Spirit, and desiring no assimilation whatever with the worldly, who cannot see or understand it, we are quite willing to bear the reproach of a peculiar people. We always refuse to be called by any other name than that of our Head -- Christians -- continually claiming that there can be no division among those continually led by his Spirit and example as made known through his Word.
Russell later suggested the usage of the name "International Bible Students Association" for local ecclesias. He deemed the use of such a name would not be sectarian, but would simply designate the Bible Students as associated with each other worldwide. In 1916, however, the legal entity in London was created and was given the name "International Bible Students Association". This apparently presented a conflict between the usage of of this by local ecclesias, and could result in conceptual and even legal confusion. Nevertheless, Russell suggested that local ecclesias use the phrase "Associated Bible Students" instead of "International Bible Students Association". Many--if not most--of the local ecclessias, however, continued to use "International Bible Students Association".
Russell continued:
We disown none of our Lord's dear children. The weakest child of the household of faith (in Christ, our Redeemer) we gladly recognize as our brother. Some, in ignorance of their privilege of the communion of saints, are mixed with the various worldly organizations, to their great detriment.
Russell here acknowledges that members of the church could be found among the sectarian organizations. This is a view that he held right up until he died, as can be seen by many things he said.
Though we cannot follow them there, we gladly welcome them when they come among us. Wherever we have hope of finding any such, in the various nominal Churches, etc., we tell them the "good tidings of great joy," and, by word and example, say, "Come out from among them (the worldly, though professing Christians) and be ye separate." How could we deliver this message if we were not obeying it? We have unbounded faith in our Captain; and this perfect organization, invisible to the world, marches on to certain and glorious victory.
http://mostholyfaith.com/Beta/bible/Reprints/Z1882OCT.asp#R407:1
That is very plainly stated, and this represents what Russell believed until his death, despite the fact that many of his associates, were promoting teachings that would result in what Russell openly preached against.
Then, in 1894, Russell stated:
This is another very direct statement. Russell continued to believe this until his death in 1916.
Here Russell openly refers to the church as consisting of saints wherever they may be found, even among the various denominations of Christendom.
Russell continued:
Russell points to such divisions (heresies) as causing separations among the people of God, and that should not be.
http://www.mostholyfaith.com/Beta/bible/Sermon/Sermon.asp?xRef=SM459
https://tinyurl.com/video-keys


Comments